Pryce, by contrast, is all earthy motion. His Bergoglio shuffles, sighs, and dances the tango in his head. He is a pope who smells of sheep, who washes the feet of the poor, and who speaks of God not in Latin syllogisms but in the silence of a rainy Buenos Aires street.
The film constructs a fictionalized private meeting in 2012 at Castel Gandolfo, where Bergoglio—having already attempted to resign as archbishop—is summoned by Benedict to discuss his departure. This meeting never happened in real life, but Meirelles and screenwriter Anthony McCarten use this dramatic license to stage a series of philosophical duels. The film’s most audacious scene occurs in the Sistine Chapel, beneath the gaze of Michelangelo’s The Last Judgment . Here, Bergoglio confesses his sins to the Pope. It is a stunning inversion of power: the future pope confessing to the current pope. But the scene is not about absolution; it is about revelation. los dos papas
Benedict represents the pre-modern Church—beautiful, silent, certain. Francis represents the postmodern Church—messy, dialogical, uncertain. When Benedict argues that the Church must resist the "dictatorship of relativism," Francis counters that the Church must stop dictating and start listening. The film does not declare a winner. Instead, it suggests that both are necessary: the structure of Ratzinger preserves the space for the compassion of Bergoglio. What makes the film so watchable, however, is its joy. After the heavy theology, there is a sequence where the two popes abandon their protocol to watch Germany beat Argentina in the 2010 World Cup. They eat pizza on the floor. They argue about offside rules. They forget, for a moment, that they are the vicars of Christ. Pryce, by contrast, is all earthy motion
In a cynical age, Los Dos Papas offers an unfashionable virtue: hope. It reminds us that two old men, arguing about God in a garden, can be more thrilling than any superhero. And that sometimes, the most revolutionary act is to listen. The film constructs a fictionalized private meeting in